AUDI A3 1.8 T FSI S Line 2dr (2008)
Ideal
I had an Audi A3 for many years and for me it struck a great balance between sensible practicality and sporty fun. It really combines all those things that are great about German cars - reliability, sturdy build and good performance.
The interiors are a good indicator of the general quality of this motor, plush and smart without being excessively flashy. The suspension is also something that I noticed in particular - it makes for a very smooth and responsive ride. Performance-wise it's excellent, too, I have the 1.8T and it's really quite fast!
The only thing I will say is that the standard equipment is pretty basic, even considering the car's age, and there isn't as much space as I might have liked inside. Apart from those two minor niggles, though, you have an excellent car in the Audi A3 - it never let me down.